| Author |
Message |
|
|
Map name: Pitbull2
Map maker: Curmudgeon
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 can't cap the same bases as P1. If P1 is S they can get marauder and stop base caps so fast it's unfair.
Change recommendations (if you have any):
Just down vote the map. Every time I play it one side has a HUGE advantage.
|
|
|
|
I happen to play Backgammon a lot. This is a bit like the backgammon proposal. The player who is winning often will pass the cube forcing the opponent to most likely resign. The only difference is that in Backgammon if the opposing player accepts the cube, then he/she has it by their side, and can be the next person to double. Only the player with the cube can pass the cube and double.
|
|
|
|
I know I posted a lot of maps. But I must add that I've played each of the maps that I have posted, some I've played multiple times.
|
|
|
Map name: Diamondsforever
Map maker: IGROUNDZERO
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 can't cap the same bases as P1. K has a serious advantage and can cap most bases.
Change recommendations (if you have any): make more starting bases for both sides or move infantry units to on top of bases.
|
|
|
|
To explain this is a little difficult, but I've played it and lost to P1 who was K. This would be easier to explain if you actually play the game.
|
|
|
Map name: Rebelstrut1
Map maker: ebbwvalefan
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, they can block P2 from taking the uncapped base. Or even cap the base.
Change recommendations: make the bases capped to start or remove the extra infantry unit.
|
|
|
Map name: capturingthestorm
Map maker: Masterwoo
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: in KvT when Titan get first turn they can mass teleport and block underling from capture their neutral for many turn this probably give titan too high resource advantage IMO (I dunno if there's anyway for K to counter this tactic though)
Change recommendations (if you have any): make fewer infantry to start.
Notes: this is from a post from the previous thread that I posted started that is in the general forums called "List of FAIR and UNFAIR rated maps"
|
|
|
Map name: findx2
Map maker: partyp88
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 can't cap the same bases as P1.
If P1 is T and P2 is S they can teleport to cap bases not capped by S very early on.
Change recommendations (if you have any): make more starting bases for both sides or move infantry units to on top of bases. Or down vote altogether.
I've played this map a few times in TVS where P2 is S. Each time S had a huuuuuuge disadvantage.
|
|
|
Map name: Gooniewarz
Map maker: miamimoose
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 can't cap the same bases as P1.
Change recommendations (if you have any): make more starting bases for both sides or move infantry units to on top of base.
|
|
|
Map name: Pond
Map maker: matt1988
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 can't cap the same bases as P1.
Change recommendations (if you have any): make more starting bases for both sides or move infantry units to on top of base.
|
|
|
Map name: Wet Summer Wipe
Map maker: Elroyomj
Number of Players: 2
Reason for down voting: If player 1 is Khral, player 2 is T or S, then P2 is at a serious disadvantage. Including the very center base.
Change recommendations (if you have any): make more starting bases for both sides and remove middle base
|
|
|
|
Yes I know. Good idea. I'll try again at some point
|
|
|
Giving a response for each map is hard, because I have to reply from my phone; but I'll do what I can.
Gruntv2 and Pond if player 1 is K they can cap an extra base on turn 1 that player 2 can't. It happened to me in both games.
|
|
|
In someone else's post from my previous thread:
guinwza wrote:I like this topic, I wish this will quickly remove all unfair map from random pool 
Please check map "capturing the strom" in KvT when Titan get first turn they can mass teleport and block underling from capture their neutral for many turn this probably give titan too high resource advantage IMO (I dunno if there's anyway for K to counter this tactic though)
also someone please advice me how to play titan on "The great wall" , I know I can defen everything flying with eclipse and walker but it's very hard to go offensive with only light units teleport especially when opponent mass tank on defense.
there's much more but i cant remember them all for now.
|
|
|
I happen to agree that Underlings are easy to pick off. But sometimes if you get enough, they can be overwhelming, even for marauders and speeders.
Ive seen opposing players do it to me.
|
![[Search]](/templates/default/images/icon_mini_search.gif){kind=icon}
![[Recent Topics]](/templates/default/images/icon_mini_recentTopics.gif){kind=icon}
![[Login]](/templates/default/images/icon_mini_login.gif){kind=icon}
Login
